Episode Transcript
[00:00:07] All right, Dieter and Hutch, we're just doing it with me tonight.
[00:00:11] I think we get Hutch a bunch down the stretch, so appreciate you all waiting as my children might be killing each other upstairs, so we might need to rush out of this one sooner rather than later, which is going to be difficult because, boy, is there a lot to get to.
[00:00:25] Just. Jesus Christ, is there a lot to get to in this game.
[00:00:30] Let's start with this. Let's start with the take that I had for the Merc, which is that Brock Purdy is just buying these guys time on a micro and macro level. Brock Purdy is playing so well that he is covering up pretty much all their sins and he is buying this 49ers defense, which needs some real work. And Jake and I talked about this extensively this past week. We. We thought the performance against the Raiders was concerning. Concerning, especially in the secondary. And I think we. We also leaned in a little bit, though. I think we were defensive at least I'll speak for myself. There was a level of defensiveness when it comes to the pass rush, and I think that maintains in this one. And we'll see on the film.
[00:01:21] But the issues that the secondary was having, communicating last week against the Raiders, I'm not even sure this week was. Was a communication issue.
[00:01:31] I think that they just got flat out beat. We'll get to all of that.
[00:01:36] We will have ample time to get to the bad. We got to start with the winners. We got to start with the good. Pie was exceptional.
[00:01:42] Christian McCaffrey was exceptional. Keenan Allen know knew like a third of the playbook and paid immediate dividends. And it looked exactly like when you watched the Colts film from Keenan Allen this year and then some of the Chargers film from last year, you're like, oh, yeah, there's like seven or eight basic concepts. Not that Keenan Allen can't handle the, you know, crazy ones, but there's like seven or eight concepts where he's immediately going to step in and pay dividends, and that's what he did. George Kittle was really good. Debo Samuel was awesome today in the right role for him, which can only exist because Keenan Allen is here taking on the role that otherwise Debo would have had to have filled. Jordan Watkins had a very nice game. Trent Williams was committing war crimes out on the field.
[00:02:29] OSA Digizua had a really nice game. Fred Warner had his moments. By Fred Warner standards, not a very nice game. But Fred Warner standards are extremely high.
[00:02:40] They have a lot of really good football players. There's Every reason to think that this team can win the Super Bowl. They got to get their act together on the back end.
[00:02:48] They got to get their act together on the back end.
[00:02:51] Purdy was near perfect today.
[00:02:55] I'm just going off the top of my head and I got all the data right here, but it won't tell this story. I think he had one bad throw all day.
[00:03:02] It was that third down to Allen where he just skipped it a little bit.
[00:03:09] One bad throw all game.
[00:03:11] Everything else was damn near Perfect. And the 74 yard touchdown, while early and not technically deciding, I think is going to get overblown, not, not in the sense of it's going to be overshadowed is the better term. Sorry. It's going to be overshadowed because they had a 66 yard touchdown and the second half was just touchdowns on touchdowns on touchdowns and they put up all these big gaudy numbers, all of them deserved against a defense. That's a joke.
[00:03:40] But that 74 yard touchdown that they had in the first half.
[00:03:45] If we're talking about Brock Purdy, NFL MVP at the end of the year, if we're making a case for Brock Purdy's candidacy at the end of the year, we lead with that play.
[00:03:56] And it's not as if he hasn't made awesome place. How many times have we seen Brock do the stop on a dime play this year? Too many times to count. Add another one to the list.
[00:04:04] But that play I think highlights everything that's going on with this football team. They're down 16 to 10. There's under three minutes to play. They're in their own territory. They're getting the ball back to start the second half. They're going, it's go time.
[00:04:19] And it all falls apart.
[00:04:21] Dallas calls the right play at the right time, nobody gets open.
[00:04:25] Brock is locked in on Allen, not because he locks in on guys, but because who else is he going to throw it to in that situation?
[00:04:37] Immediately beaten off the right side and McKivitz did a nice job to recover and do the bull ring.
[00:04:43] But Brock steps up in the pocket to avoid that pressure.
[00:04:47] And then Caleb Downs is coming from the A gap. Connor Colby is belly flopped in the middle of the field. He just whiffed, entirely whiffed. And boy will we get to Connor Colby later.
[00:04:59] Brock just goes little, little right trigger on Madden. Just out of the way.
[00:05:05] Keeps his eyes up the whole time. Chaos around him. He's an itty bitty guy. Chaos around him the whole time.
[00:05:12] Keeps his eyes up, seeing stuff, developing. Realizes ain't none of these sons of open.
[00:05:17] I'm rolling out to the right. We're going to do our little Brock pie dance.
[00:05:23] Gets the linebacker. He's jumping into the sidelines. By the time he turns around, Christian McAffrey, who was standing just with the offensive lineman just standing around, he. He realizes, oh, Brock still got it. He just starts running towards the end zone.
[00:05:37] Brock feels that. He feels it. And this is what I talk about with quarterback feel.
[00:05:43] You don't have time to recognize, see it, you have to feel it. You have to have some sort of supernatural power to have the map out in front of you, FIFA style and understand this guy is here even if I can't see him. Peripheral vision. I thought Brady had a great term today. Soft eyes.
[00:05:59] Soft eyes, yeah, I'm seeing it, but I'm not like locking in. I'm not taking it all in. I can see the colors. The spectrum is perfect for him.
[00:06:11] And man, not like, not like some supernatural throw or anything, but brock stands, delivers 15 yards in stride on a dime. And there was no one around McCaffrey. He runs into the end zone and boy, did he look fast when there's no one around him. He's fast as hell. And he was fast as hell on this one. Wrote a column on Friday about how Prime Christian McCaffrey is back. And we went over some of the numbers on Friday where McCaffrey's doing some stuff that he hasn't done and frankly didn't do even during his MVP caliber season in 23.
[00:06:41] And it doesn't feel as apparent because the workload isn't as high because Kalon Black is doing a lot of those things. And in the second half, I had a lot of people on the Everything app hit me up like, what's the matter with McCaffrey? What's the matter with McCaffrey? Well, no, it's a game that was better suited for Kalon Black. You think about that Dallas defensive line and they are just big boys going straight. They can't handle contain worth the. Worth a damn. They couldn't, as evidenced by their double reverse touchdown scored against.
[00:07:10] But that game was built for Kalon Black and pass protection, which McCaffrey is a fine pass protector. Black decleated Quentin Williams today. I'm going to go ahead and say Kaylan Black's a better pass pass pro guy, even if he doesn't hit him all the time when he hits him. Spectacular.
[00:07:28] And then Black has been a better outside zone runner so far this year. And what I posited earlier this Week is that effectively because defenses have sold out to break the outside zone. A lot of the traits that you would ascribe to outside zone runners are actually better suited now for more like Le'Veon Bell types, which McCaffrey can be and has been this year.
[00:07:50] And you want that between the tackles. You want the patience, the vision, the letting things happen between the tackles. Not necessarily with run with gap stuff, but just in the sense of if you're just trying to read it, get to the outside like those reads, you know, hey, A, B, C. And we're going to hit one of the three, like that's not there anymore because of the way teams have set up their defenses, the way they blitz, just the width of defensive lines across the league, which boy are we going to see it next week against the Vikings.
[00:08:18] But in general with these sort of quasi chaos defenses, you're not getting that. So what you want is typically what you would describe as between the tackles. Runners for the outside stuff, just go, just go as hard as you can, as fast as you can.
[00:08:33] And that's Kalon Black, that touchdown run today.
[00:08:39] Yeah, I'm gonna remember that one for a while. Bad day to be a big Caleb Downs truther. As your boy is. Bad day to be a Caleb Downs truther.
[00:08:50] Yikes, yikes. Regardless though, Black, we're going to forget about that last fumble and we're going to talk about the good things that he did because I thought he did some really, really good things beyond even the touchdown run. He had a couple outside runs late in the game that were well suited for him. And then they came back and hit it with the Christian McCaffrey inside of Trent's ass touchdown run.
[00:09:11] When the run game got going, the 49ers offense was unbeatable, but it really wasn't going in the first half. It was fine, it was palatable, but it wasn't going.
[00:09:21] Brock had them with the lead going into halftime off of some Russell Wilson and he's done that a lot this season.
[00:09:30] And then now everything's cooking. Now I'm really going.
[00:09:34] I thought he, I thought he had an MVP level performance. I mean, Dak Prescott just real quickly, Dak Prescott today went for 343 yards, five touchdowns, one interception, one sack against.
[00:09:47] He was clearly the second best quarterback in this game, clearly. Unquestionably.
[00:09:54] Brock, 22 for 28, 389, three touchdowns, five sacks against the QBRS at 82. If you go on the expected QBR, which doesn't take into account the sacks, it was 94. And the best way to think about QBR, and this is the ESPN1 not rating rating. He was at 100 and 54. Five, which is.
[00:10:15] He was one touchdown shy of a perfect rating today.
[00:10:18] If, if you break down the numbers, if he had four touchdowns today, it would have been a perfect rating, but at 94qbr, which again, I, I don't hold the sacks against him, though I think it's fair to maybe have that conversation in the sense of, like, quarterbacks are responsible for some sacks.
[00:10:39] If you were to think 94, that means that you effectively have a 94 chance of winning any game if a quarterback plays at that level.
[00:10:48] Dak Prescott today had an 87 QBR, which I guess actually lines up with the 46 to 40 win for the Niners. But it is, it is awesome. It is awesome seeing a quarterback operating at this level. And let's not pretend that the Dallas Cowboys defense isn't a fucking joke.
[00:11:05] They're an embarrassment and they made the Raiders look downright competent last week.
[00:11:12] But what should you do against bad defenses? You should kick their ass. You should not leave it to chance. Brock Purdy didn't leave anything to chance in this game.
[00:11:21] It didn't leave anything to chance in the last game. The defense did, though, at least in this one. And I'm fascinated to see how this manifests forward because I was able to watch a little bit of the Vikings packers game today.
[00:11:36] We will get into the deep film breakdown, but initial takeaway.
[00:11:40] Oh boy, oh boy. This could be a real issue because Connor Colby was a sieve today and Quentin Williams is a hell of a football player. I don't want to take anything away from any of the big fellas up front for Dallas. They have some beef up there.
[00:11:56] They absolutely got some beef.
[00:11:59] Ogbanya is pretty awesome as well.
[00:12:04] Clark had some moments especially early, but mercy me, the way Connor Colby played today is a benchable offense. And there were a few of those.
[00:12:15] I think I tweeted out somewhere in the second quarter that you need to go and you need to put d' Amador Lenore on the bench. He doesn't have it today.
[00:12:22] And I could appreciate d' Amador is playing injured with a foot injury and that it might be pretty hard to play cornerback with a foot injury, but once you're out there, I got to take you for what you are. Like, you don't get to be graded on the curve once an NFL game starts. And I think George Pickens is still dragging his ass.
[00:12:39] I think George Pickens is out there. I think he just got another five receptions for another 100 yards.
[00:12:44] CD Lamb didn't have a catch until the second half because they didn't need one from CD Lamb. Now we can argue the first drive in the the oh for four start for Prescott was they could have used a catch from CD Lamb there. But on the whole, Dak didn't even bother looking over Ronaldo Green's way. And it's not because Ronaldo Green was playing some superb game, he was good.
[00:13:08] But it was simply because two had no chance against three, no chance whatsoever.
[00:13:14] And the safety play remained suspect. And that is the nicest way of putting it. All the stuff that we were seeing against the Raiders, which really brought pause and everyone's I a lot of the takes out of that game against the Raiders were is this a Super bowl worthy defense? And I'm like, I'm not sure you're familiar with Las Vegas, Las Vegas Raiders football, but you can go ahead and write that this is not a Super bowl worthy defense.
[00:13:40] This is a defense that has a lot of problems. Now the good part is there's some talent on this defense and I do think that these things can be hashed out. I don't know if they will, but I think they can be hashed out.
[00:13:51] But that was an abysmal defensive performance today and it was only bailed out because you had an exceptional offensive performance and you had two running backs who were punching it yet Debo Samuel, again perfectly in the gadget role. You had George Kittle, who imagine what would have happened if he hadn't been interfered at least two, perhaps even three times in this game. Though I don't mind a little bump and go.
[00:14:13] Heaven knows the Niners needed it in this one.
[00:14:16] So for all the complaints about the calls, I can appreciate them. I also understand that this is a makeshift crew and maybe we should, you know, lower our expectations a little bit for perfection. But I'd rather see them play a little.
[00:14:32] Like I would. I would rather see like bang bang play. Maybe he got there a little bit too soon. Like play some football. Same way I like watching basketball. I need some, I need some uncalled fouls every now and again you want to call everything, it's going to be a boring as hell game. And the Niners again, like the idea of, oh well, it only hurt the Niners. Like I saw some deep throws to the sideline that could have gone the other way.
[00:14:56] And ultimately I think the Cowboys scored on those plays anywhere on those drives anyway. But Like I saw some Lenore plays, I saw some Green plays where they could have been flagged if we were being really nitpicky about it, but they weren't and I thought it evened out on the whole that was at least my take. I'm sure that a more biased mind and it's not pejorative in the sense of bias mind, if you're a fan, you're a fan, you're going to see it your way.
[00:15:19] But I, I didn't, I, I wasn't too worried about any of that stuff. I really wasn't. What I liked from the defenses and a lot of this is game script, but I thought that they did a better job against the run in the second half.
[00:15:36] Yeah, that's about it.
[00:15:37] That's about it on the D. That Mikel was awesome in this game. He had two, three, four bull rushes that just destroyed Terrence Steele.
[00:15:48] Bosa, let's talk Bosa for a second.
[00:15:54] It's not 2023 anymore.
[00:15:56] It just isn't. And the expectation that Nick Bosa is supposed to be a game record still is just way behind the times.
[00:16:04] You can point to his contract and say, well, you know, he's a $30 million pass rusher. Why isn't he playing like a $30 million pass rusher?
[00:16:10] Well, I got a pretty good reason why he's coming off of injury and his legs aren't the same size.
[00:16:15] It might take a minute and it might not even be there. It's his third ACL tear in his career. That's like asking why the guy who's had three Tommy John surgeries can't get it up to 98 anymore. Like there's a reason that his contract is probably on the chopping block at the end of this year. And that was the case before he even came back from this second, second stint away.
[00:16:38] I thought he's been fine, legitimately fine. The Dre Greenlaw should have been interception was a Nick Bosa play.
[00:16:45] He had a, another really good pressure that was negated by another d' or Lenor penalty late one on a two man rush against again Terence Steele, who had a pretty tough day.
[00:16:56] I think it's going to continue to get better.
[00:16:59] I think he's coming back from an injury. I think he's really coming back from a massive injury, really for the first time now, like now his legs are under him a little bit more.
[00:17:10] And I'm not saying, not guaranteeing, I'm not predicting that he's going to turn into old Nick Bosa. But I thought this game, at least from broadcast view, was better than the last game, and I thought the last game was getting dogged on for no particularly good reason. And this is all about expectations versus reality.
[00:17:31] Again, the expectation that Nick Bosa is going to come back and look like prime. Nick Bosa again, is flawed on like four or five different fronts to the point where you probably don't think he's ever getting back to that point, which sucks for the Niners because they could sure as hell use somebody like that.
[00:17:50] But ultimately I just, I I feel like he's being used as a scapegoat. I do think there's probably a political undercurrent to all that. Fair enough. You can like and dislike whomever you care, you know, to like and dislike. I don't think he's going to get a lot of benefit from the doubt in the San Francisco Bay Area market when it comes to stuff like this. But when it, when it gets down to brass tacks, the guy's getting pressures.
[00:18:13] And yeah, sacks would be great if it's a pressure that turns into a sack.
[00:18:19] So finish the play.
[00:18:21] But the pressure is the most important thing.
[00:18:24] The the pressure is the start. There's a lot of guys who get sacks but don't have any pressures. They just show up for two or three plays a game and the rest of the time they're barbecue chicken. That's not Bosa. He's giving you good run defense. He's giving you pretty consistent push. There's a lot of double teams going his way. They've been chipping him with with tight ends, as they always really have, and I'm curious to see how much that changes now moving forward, because now Buckner really does need to be reckoned with in a serious way because Mikel looked really good today and now you got to reckon with that.
[00:18:58] I'm curious to see if Raheem Morris Ranch ratchets ratchets it up a little bit more or if he tries to tone it down a little bit more. I don't know the right direction, but he got caught a couple times today and he's been caught fairly frequently over the last couple of weeks. Atlanta got him a couple times. Washington in the second half got him a couple times.
[00:19:21] I, I I'm not sure he got caught in the second half against Seattle as much as the Niners just sort of started falling apart.
[00:19:29] Clint got him a couple times in the second half of the Raiders game, though. At that point, did it really matter? And then yeah, I Thought Clayton Adams got him a couple times too. But ultimately, you know, Dallas was moving the ball in pretty straightforward ways and the stunts and some of the, the chaos that they were playing with earlier just hasn't really been there. Is one of the concerns that bringing Bosa back, like, how's this all going to work? Because he's never really done stuff like that before.
[00:19:58] It seems as if they pared it down on the defensive line, especially then throwing Buckner into the mix.
[00:20:05] But now you're going to have a week away in Colorado Springs, a game where you better bring it against a quarterback that you just saw last week, though, albeit very different circumstances around him, and a defense that I think now has to face the reality of our secondary is not a strength where he, Morris, was going to talk himself into it all year and there were certainly moments early in the year where you go, hell yeah, let's do this thing. Green's playing at a high level and Nora's playing at a high level. You're getting away with it at safety, but you know, hey, you get away with it where you can get away with it. You got Fred, you got Dre, like certainly the first four or five weeks of the season you're looking at it and saying this is a back to front football team. And now I think you might have to switch it around because Lenore is not going to get any healthier.
[00:20:56] Green had to leave this game with the back thing that he got on the interception last week.
[00:21:02] Upton Stout is, Upton Stout is just, he might as well have an arrow above his head on every play.
[00:21:11] He's a fun player. He's getting exposed now, is not a well rounded player and it's something that we always thought could happen. But when you have really good, well rounded players around him, it doesn't really bear itself out all that much. And now it's starting to bear itself out a little bit and then the safety rotation is just got to stop. It's just got to stop. You got to pick two and I don't know who those two are. I think all three of them have had very clear reasons to not pick them.
[00:21:43] The track record is longest with Jair, but Malik Mustafa did not have a particularly good game today, at least from, you know, my first watch, though it's very difficult with the Fox broadcast.
[00:21:54] I, I, I'm still not quite sure what Siegel was doing on one of those Pickens touchdowns where it was cover four and then he crashes into the flat. Presuming I, I guess that the running back is about to break through the line, but he jumped it way too early and then gave Dak the very clear window as Lenore is just dragging his foot behind him.
[00:22:17] I can't qualify that as good safety play, even if it was justifiable in its decision because wasn't reading the play right.
[00:22:26] All three of them have every reason to not be on the field. Not a great place to start if you're trying to pick two of them.
[00:22:33] I'm not sure what combination works, but clearly Ray Morris doesn't know either. And this is why I, as much as I loved the Buckner move, as much as I thought the key that the the Keenan Allen move was going to really work for this team and I think immediately paid out exactly what you'd expect.
[00:22:53] It's why I couldn't get over the hump with praise. Not that that's uncommon for me at the trade deadline because what you put Jack Jones back on your practice squad like you needed somebody in the secondary. You needed a depth corner back, you needed, I don't know, Nate Hobbs to be healthy. What the hell was that this week? You needed another safety who at least you could lock down one of the spots. You needed to do something in the secondary because again, you could only work off the information that you had coming out of that Raiders game. And that Raiders game was just, I mean, it was the people's republic. It was red flags everywhere, man.
[00:23:33] And that shit is going to burn you down the stretch.
[00:23:40] It is. The Niners have a lot of the tenants that I look for in a Super bowl winning team. I think they do a very good job in stopping the run. Helps to have Fred Warner, but, you know, their defensive line is stout in that regard. Pardon the punishment. And OSA Digizua has looked awesome in run defense since Buckner has gotten there. That is not a coincidence.
[00:24:04] You have ends that are absolutely built to stop the run and corners that can tackle Lenore more so than Green. Stout is just going to stick his head in there no matter what.
[00:24:14] Mustafa absolutely lines up on that. So I feel good about their run defense.
[00:24:20] I love the way they. They're running the football now. I love this one, two punch.
[00:24:26] I think the pass game with Purdy at the helm is only going to improve from here as Keenan Allen gets more of the playbook, as you know, theoretically. Who's to say Mike Evans comes back with Debo in the right role with Jordan Watkins clearly carving out a role for himself.
[00:24:43] Great blocking today from. From Jordan Watkins going from, I think a repugnant Blocker to the point where I had unsolicited people in the building letting me know about it because they know I'm into that kind of shit.
[00:24:59] Going from that to then, pretty good.
[00:25:03] Not great. Pretty good is a big thing for the 49ers, and that keeps him on the field, and he can make some plays when he's on the field.
[00:25:12] So if that's your fourth, fifth wide receiver you're in. You're in really good position. You're in a really good position.
[00:25:21] You got Evans.
[00:25:23] Theoretically, you have Allen.
[00:25:27] I'll also add, theoretically, there they be old Watkins. Debo Cowing's in there a little bit. Maybe Stribling. I mean, the past game should. And it was. It was there today. Should be in a really good spot. And that is not even taking into account George Kittle. That's not even taking into account either Black or obviously McCaffrey.
[00:25:51] Jordan James can get in on that action. Like, I think they're going to be able to move the ball through the air and on the ground.
[00:25:57] Now, the issues with through the air is, is Brock constantly getting pressure right. Right at left guard? The answer is probably yes. Wouldn't shock me at all if they.
[00:26:08] Oh, I don't even know. I mean, I guess you have to ride with Connor Colby next week. I. I would not throw Carver Willis or Austin Pleasance or Rando Guy off the street to the.
[00:26:20] Against the Vikings. I would be like, hey, if you got it in you, we're gonna need to see it now. 75, and I don't think that's gonna go well, but I'm not really sure there's a clear better option. If it doesn't go well, then.
[00:26:33] Then you're kind of done with it and you move forward and Seattle's not a hell of a lot better. But you roll with it from there. At least you know you have a problem and you don't prolong the inevitable.
[00:26:46] Minnesota's front is so dynamic and so frightening to me. Even without any brand name, say, for maybe Dallas Turner, I.
[00:26:55] I just think that would be malpractice to throw a guy who's never played a competitive game at guard in his life.
[00:27:02] In Carver Willis at the position like that, it doesn't seem fair.
[00:27:09] But what's fairness have to do with any of this?
[00:27:12] So there's that. That that might stop them from moving the ball as well as they could, but they'll move the ball through the air anyway. The question is, can they stop the pass?
[00:27:20] And if you think about the teams that they're, well, we're going to see with Minnesota if they can actually move the ball through the air. Kirk obviously lifted their floor. I'm not sure they have that high of a ceiling offensively, but doesn't really matter with that defense. We might be getting into just strict 2025 Seahawks territory with them where it's like, yeah, so long as the offense isn't a complete train wreck, they'll win the game.
[00:27:43] We'll find out next week.
[00:27:45] But if you think about, you know, the bona fide playoff teams here, and I still consider Green Bay to be one of them, I mean there are two that should scare the living out of the 49ers and the bears and the packers.
[00:27:57] And that's to say nothing of the possibility of Seattle. Now with Drew Locke kind of figuring it out, though there's debate to be had there and obviously the Rams, if, well, I don't know. I think staff probably washed. But you're going to run through one of those two teams, if not both of them in the playoffs and one seed on the line Sunday night in Mexico City.
[00:28:20] But you're going to be running through the Bears or the packers in the playoffs almost assuredly.
[00:28:26] And those two teams can slang it, you might have to play the Cowboys again. Probably not, but maybe, I mean, I don't know.
[00:28:35] So I'm, I'm in the same position everyone else is in. I mean, I'm not rooting for an outcome. But the Niners are in a spot where basically they are putting all of their faith in Raheem Morris to get this thing figured out. And I'll say this, that's a hell of a lot of a better place to be than trusting Robert Sala to figure it out. Because at least Raheem Morris is a secondary guy. But the secondary is a real problem. It's a real issue and it's not going to get any healthier.
[00:29:05] So they're going to need to figure out some things that they can do because if there is anything good happening with the pass rush, and I lean towards right now that the pass rush is doing well enough and the secondary is failing them. But even if that's not the case, one of those two units has to step up in a big way. And I don't think this pass rush, save for the possibility of a BOSA improvement, which I, I expect to a degree, but I'm not sure to what degree.
[00:29:35] I'm not sure this pass rush has, you know, four sack of game potential in it. I don't think that's what it's built for.
[00:29:43] And I think that if they were to start to do that, they would leave themselves open for a lot of explosive plays with stunts and things like that where if they're selling out to get to the quarterback, they might be burned by splashing the pot a little bit, but they're not playing complimentary football on defense. They're just simply not. And Dallas burned them again. We saw it against the Raiders. A little bit of burn there. I think Atlanta got their licks in.
[00:30:13] I don't know what Kirk Cousins does the second go around here and I don't know what Drew Lock or Sam Darnold do.
[00:30:20] And I'm certainly not thinking, hey, J.J. mcCarthy's going to rip them apart. And I don't think Matt Stafford, who I haven't checked today but had one completion of 20 plus yards this season going into today's game, or even Justin Herbert. Now you're seeing the trend here.
[00:30:37] There's a couple of teams in a row where they might not get burned. There might be weeks, we might go a month without the Niner secondary getting burned like they got burned again today.
[00:30:47] And then the final two games of the year, that's not going to be the issue because you got Arizona and the Eagles. But that Dec. 27 game against Kansas City, that will be the litmus test because for all of Kansas City's offensive warts, it's still Patrick Mahomes.
[00:31:04] And the Niners might get a false sense of confidence out of some of these games coming up here, at least in the secondary. Like, hey, we figured it out. You'll find out if it's figured out two days after Christmas or maybe uncre. They might flex that thing. There's a lot of flexing possibilities. I've been on the phone. There's a lot of flexing possibilities. I would not book travel to Thursday night football on December 17, let me just put it that way. And so, I mean they'll play it on Saturday or Sunday, but like I don't think that game's happening.
[00:31:37] I definitely think that they're this one's 50 50.
[00:31:41] The January 3rd Sunday Night Football game might be in the middle of the afternoon.
[00:31:46] It might not be a 5:20pm Pacific God's time zone game.
[00:31:51] All that to say the issues that have shown up now might not be fully ironed out, but they got an opportunity, ironically against, you know, a team with the one seat on the line against a division rival against a first place team. I don't know if they'll still be a first place team. And I don't even know if they're still a first place team as we speak now in the Giants and against the Rams. Like there might be some times for this 49ers secondary to think, oh no, we're okay.
[00:32:19] They're going to find out the hard way on the 27th one way or another, and by then it's probably too late.
[00:32:26] So they need to hash this stuff out. And you're going to need to see exceptional secondary games at least once or twice between now and two days after Christmas. Like that. That's the standard that needs to be set right now if we're going to do an expectations versus reality thing. You're going to need to see a couple of exceptional secondary games to trust that they've ironed out their issues. Because good enough won't be good enough. Once you get to the playoffs, once you have to play the Bears, once you have to play the packers, once there's teams that can just go right over the top on you, there's not many of them.
[00:33:00] That's when you really find out if your secondary is there. And I think Kansas City can probably do that to them. But luckily the schedules kind in that regard. But nothing looked kind today. Nothing looked kind today on that. Again, Purdy's just buying them time and they're in a really great spot at 8 and 1 control in their hands.
[00:33:21] They, they need to have their best week of practice this week to get themselves to a point where they can do anything against this Vikings defense and to where, you know, and Kyle's really got a lock in. I, I have no idea. And until I get into the deep film, I won't even have a, a inkling of an idea of what the hell you do.
[00:33:43] Kyle, obviously much, much, much, much, much, much, much better than me at any of this. But like, if I don't have a single idea, I'm sure Kyle has a million of them and I'm sure they'll try to execute it, but man, don't even know where you start to attack that defense and then, hey, you lose that game. Now control of the NFC is out of your hands.
[00:34:06] So this is, this is a big one coming up. This is a big one coming up. And it was big that they won this game because we'd be having, I mean, this is coming across as negative, Nancy. Now imagine what it would have been like had they actually lost it. And boy, did they seem like they wanted to give this thing away at a Couple of junctures, but again, the good things. That backfield has the juice for the 49ers. Brock Purdy is playing at an MVP level. Keenan Allen immediately gives you exactly what you were looking for. And imagine what happens when he learns the actual playbook.
[00:34:37] Kittle is still as good as it gets at the tight end position. I have no idea how. I have some inklings, but we're not going to publicly air them.
[00:34:46] And there are some things that are happening on the defensive front that if you can pair it with just competent secondary play, could really wreak some havoc against maybe not elite offensive teams, but very, very good ones.
[00:35:04] But we saw last year what happened with this. I mean, they got into shootouts down the stretch. The entire end of the season was shootouts, and it didn't inspire confidence going into the playoffs.
[00:35:14] So it will.
[00:35:17] It'll be telling. It'll be telling. I don't think that. I don't think that anyone's going to survive two months of shootouts.
[00:35:25] I mean, it could be fun, but today was a Big 12 game. That's not my kind of football.
[00:35:31] I'm the Mark Jackson meme right now. What happened to the game that I love?
[00:35:34] Like, it was. It was fun, but also like, man, they ran cover zero on a second and nine down by a touchdown. When the Niners are in there, like, what are we doing here?
[00:35:46] It's terrible defense from Dallas, and great that Brock was just like, I guess I'll take that. Thank you. McCaffrey's sitting there like, wait a minute, there's no one around me again.
[00:35:56] But it's still, you know, the. The double. The double reverse. I mean, it. Could it have worked any better?
[00:36:02] It was like nine against one going the other way.
[00:36:06] And we talked about that on Friday. Like, they. The Cowboys always take the cheese, but because Brock was able to push this thing forward, keep the offense on track, it allowed Kyle to call that right play at the exact right time. Same thing with Debo's first touchdown, which is very reminiscent. Different formation, but very reminiscent of the touchdown he had in the 2021 playoffs.
[00:36:28] Just that screen and go.
[00:36:32] So a lot of really cool stuff to work with, but it's hard to. It's hard to pay attention to it when the circus music is blaring from the defensive side of the ball, and it's particularly glaring for blaring from the secondary.
[00:36:49] That's enough of my rambling. Let's get into some questions here.
[00:36:53] And we're just going to do the supers and then I'm going to take a minute or two, read through some of the regular comments, and we'll get to all of them, but appreciate you very much.
[00:37:02] All right, here we go. Oh, and thank you to everyone who joined in. Really do appreciate it. Jake is doing some crazy stuff with sickos football, and we're super excited to. To share that with all of you. So who are. Who are at the deepest, deepest sickness of the levels, and then, you know, we've started grinding a little bit more. It's been me sort of running a solo operation. Understandably so, because, again, depravity. But we're starting to get into the 27 draft class in a little bit more earnestness, and it is every bit as good, if not better, than we've been talking it up to this point. So very exciting stuff. Very exciting times. You know, I saw Stuart, the incredible defensive end for South Carolina, throwing a fit on the sidelines. He's already been suspended once this season. And I'm just thinking to myself, as somebody who wants to see great players on the San Francisco 49ers, I'm just thinking about, just keep it up, buddy. Just keep it up and you'll be there at 31 or 32. Just keep it up.
[00:37:58] This is the kind of weird stuff we're into. So appreciate you guys joining us here. Thanks for the entertainment. I mean, we'll call it entertainment if you want. Most of the times it's just Deeter rambling, and then Jake comes in, and sometimes we get entertaining. We had a weird story last week.
[00:38:13] All right, here we go. Some bad calls, but this team has been undisciplined the last three games and too many penalties.
[00:38:19] Yeah, I agree with that. I mean, here's the thing. Bad teams typically look undisciplined when you're having. When you have bad players, they typically make penalties. And the deterioration of this secondary.
[00:38:34] The question mark that you have at left guard, I mean, question marks, understating it, the sieve that you have at left guard, some of the, you know, Jacob Cowing's out here in formation.
[00:38:47] The. The floor of this team, because of all these injuries, is where it was in 23 and 24. And in 24, it obviously bore fruit.
[00:38:58] The floor of this team is pretty apparent. And when you get to that floor, consciously or subconsciously, guys are going to overcompensate. And when you have bad players in big situations, they're going to commit penalties. It's just how it goes. I have not liked their discipline over the last three games. At all. It's telling that you couldn't tell which was the more undisciplined team. The Dallas Cowboys, who. Whose entire shtick this year is we take too many penalties and we're completely undisciplined, or the San Francisco 49ers.
[00:39:30] Couldn't tell.
[00:39:32] Not great.
[00:39:34] Not great.
[00:39:36] Dissonant dissonance. Cowboys playing man coverage is exposing the O line, making Purdy hold the ball a couple ticks longer. That's the playbook until Evans comes back. Yeah, that's been the playbook for a couple of years now.
[00:39:46] We'll have to. I mean, I'll have to really take a look at it. It's very difficult to catch it on the broadcast. Appreciate you being able to see that.
[00:39:52] Not for me. Mainly, I was just staring at 75 the whole time to see what hilarious thing he would do next. But the question with this team has always been, can they beat press man to man? And the answer is fundamentally no.
[00:40:09] Now, they built a roster going into this year that actually could have. And that was Mike Evans, that was Ricky Piersol, that was Dejon Stribling.
[00:40:22] And now you're back to what you can get. And what you can get, if you're a Kyle Shanahan offense is a bunch of guys who can beat zone because you can draw it up against Zone better than anybody.
[00:40:33] And, yeah, it's. It's tough. It's tough. When Evans comes back, you get a man beater. Again, if stribling comes, and the stribling thing is hard, you don't want to put any stock in Stribling coming back. Not because he won't come back, but because, I mean, in the same context, I just threw out there with, like, Carver Willis at left guard. Like, hey, buddy, we're playing Kansas City on December 27th. You think you can give us 30 snaps?
[00:40:59] Could really use you against Mansour, Delane and Fulton and all them. I could really use you, buddy. I know you've not played a full NFL game yet, but, like, you're good for this one, right? It's only December, and this is a critical game between a possible super bowl matchup. But you'll be okay, right?
[00:41:17] So I don't want to throw that on anybody. And even somebody who looked as awesome as he did throughout training camp and the preseason, and not like he was just showing up for preseason. I mean, every day in training camp, it was just stribling, stribling, stribling to the point where I sounded crazy sitting in the car after every practice and Being like, yeah, I think he's the best receiver on the team.
[00:41:40] I now Evans was the best receiver, but he was in a fun challenge of could he practice more than two days in a row? And the answer was no.
[00:41:49] So we all fully expected that Mike Evans was going to miss time this year. Anyone who didn't was just living a delusional existence.
[00:41:59] Man's got Achilles tendonitis.
[00:42:02] That shit don't go away.
[00:42:04] So it's just a question of how long you can push it until he feels all right about it and then, hey, hope he doesn't make a cut wrong.
[00:42:15] I don't know. I don't know. When Evans comes back, they're going to keep saying he's close.
[00:42:19] That's not the issue.
[00:42:20] The issue is can they get him over the hump? And I think the answer to that, to where the Achilles tendinitis isn't something that's going to just be omnipresent. And I think the answer to that is no. But I, of course, am, you know, only a renowned medical doctor.
[00:42:34] All right, what else we have here? But it's a great call by dissonant dissonance. Like the man coverage thing has been a huge issue since, well, the super bowl, you know, the last one, the end of the 23 season when Steve Spagnolo spent two weeks just realizing, oh, they can't beat this. Let's just press them all the time.
[00:42:56] And as soon as they started, there was, there was no answer. They damn near won that game. But that was McCaffrey, McCaffrey, McCaffrey. And then the next year, as the world crumbled around them, that was all they saw. And then last year again, it was a lot of what they saw, though not exclusively.
[00:43:16] And the, the Mac Jones of it kind of took some of that off.
[00:43:21] But, you know, it was Juwan Jennings and man to man, he doesn't like beat man to man, which meant you just threw a bunch of 50, 50 balls towards one Jennings.
[00:43:27] Same thing with Seattle. I know Seattle plays zone, but it effectively functions as man.
[00:43:33] And at least in it's, it's how, you know, how it's pressing up on the line of scrimmage and such. And so especially with some of the COVID eight concepts that they do. And so, yeah, you're just throwing 50, 50 balls up there.
[00:43:46] I like their chances on the 50, 50 balls, by the way, moving forward when you have bigger bodied receivers, right? Like if Watkins is just there to be a clear out merchant, that's fine by me because that means Evans and Allen and they got big dad bods now though Evans is still too skinny, frighteningly skinny.
[00:44:07] But those are big bodied receivers that you can throw 50, 50 balls to and I like their chances in a 5050 battle.
[00:44:15] So you're better, you're better now having those two. The problem is you don't really have those two. And the second one comes, the other one's probably leaving and we're just going to do a much higher end version of the Kadero Hodge Malik Turner game.
[00:44:28] Shout out if you know what we're talking about.
[00:44:30] Shout out for that 11 second punt by 15. Hell yes.
[00:44:35] I will never forgive myself for questioning Corliss Weightman. I do not know ball. I deserve to be tarred and feathered in the town square. He has been a sneaky mvp.
[00:44:50] It's a very different thing but a sneaky mvp. Also doing kickoffs today which interested to get Brant Boyer's perspective on why. I mean the presumption is that they just hated Eddie's kickoffs. That they were two line drive. They didn't have enough hang time. He couldn't place them in the right spot. It was maybe actually now I gotta go on a Friday and actually ask these questions.
[00:45:15] But I can't even go this Friday. They're in Colorado Springs. Maybe I'll start driving now. But with boy you're like maybe there's something to Eddie's missing his extra points because he's stretching himself too much on kickoffs. There might be something there. I would like to have a conversation about that. I need to send some text messages as soon as this is done because that just popped in my head. But Waitman looked good on the kickoffs and there was a varying level of depth. The kick coverage looked better today to say the least.
[00:45:47] This was the right game to do it with Turpin back there and I feel bad for Saran Neal with the face mask penalty but I thought they were good on special teams today, all things considered. And yeah, what a punt. What a punt. Were they trying to block that? Because they sure as hell didn't do a very good job. Dallas and Corliss Weightman. Absolutely.
[00:46:09] I mean I wish I had a wedge game like that. That was really high level stuff from number 15 by the way, as the numerolog in the 49ers YouTube space.
[00:46:23] Keenan Allen wearing three approved.
[00:46:30] Christian Kirk ain't coming back.
[00:46:32] Not that, not that. We were really wondering if he would but no, we're done with that now.
[00:46:38] So glad they used up a designate to Return on him. Just couldn't cut them, could you? Understood. The circumstances were dire. Just had to keep them around. Just had to use up one of those spots.
[00:46:48] Heaven knows, you know, you're not the most injured team in the NFL every fucking year. Might have been a good idea to, I don't know, play it safe, but I guess that's what they thought they were doing at the time. Tough spot to be in, but boy howdy, by the way, should be noted the other guy. They use that on Austin Pleasants. They did try out at left guard mid game in the preseason. Do they do the same this week? Do they say, Austin Pleasants, get your ass on a plane to Colorado Springs if you can.
[00:47:13] We'll see.
[00:47:15] Planes are up in the air. Start driving. Austin Pleasance, maybe.
[00:47:20] Maybe. Because I think they're going to. They're hopping on that plane right now and they're going to pull it up and they're going to look at 75 and they're going to be like, something must be done. And I'm not sure what the right answer there is some. Sometimes it's just as simple as you play the other guy. It can't be worse.
[00:47:41] Offensive line play, never that straightforward. But we might be approaching it. We might be approaching it. Shout out to my man Jo C. Who was bringing it with the tweets all day. Love Josie's tweets. If you don't follow him on Twitter, give him a follow on Twitter. I'm gonna steal your joke right now. Joe. Joe JC The.
[00:47:58] The. If we don't try.
[00:48:01] Oh, God damn it. I should get this right. Oh, yeah. If we don't try. Kalon Black for. For killing Caleb Downs. There were not a country of laws. Very apt. Very apt. Our good friend Brad Jones. Aussie, Aussie, Aussie. How much do we take into account that what Brady was saying in the fourth quarter, the defense was just gassed in those last two touchdown drives. I buy it. I buy it.
[00:48:22] But listen, if you don't have that much of an engine to begin with and you're running out of gas, not a lot of horsepower, not a lot of horsepower. Defensive lines certainly look gassed.
[00:48:33] I'm not terribly surprised by that. In the way that they play 1 and 2. The physicality of Dallas's offensive line, which I think we probably didn't give enough credence to in the pregame, but, like, they don't move well, but they'll punch you directly in the neck repeatedly. And there's some big mall and sons of bitches on that Dallas offensive line, which is fine, average, but they're mean and they're big and that stuff does take a wear on you. I mean, Romello height is.
[00:49:08] Might have vertigo after this one. I mean, his head has got to be spinning. I saw him get picked up, hit by another guy and thrown straight to the ground.
[00:49:16] There was a lot of that stuff today. This was a man versus man trench war and I actually thought the Niners got as much as they gave in that regard.
[00:49:28] In terms of flash and all those highlight plays, I don't know if today was the day for that. And I do think that, yeah, that's going to wear you down. Just being in a 15 round prize fight with all these offensive possessions, that's going to stink. I actually. How many possessions were there in this game? Because.
[00:49:49] Dallas. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. Okay, so nothing crazy, but when they're giving you the business, it feels heavier, I imagine.
[00:50:02] Okay, 808 rush could be better, but why are DBs always 8 to 10 yards off the line of scrimmage? No rush can get there in time when your DBs are so off. I mean, that's kind of what they have to do.
[00:50:13] Because when you're getting beat in foot races 8 to 10 yards off the line of scrimmage, what the hell do you think is going to happen? If you're pressing them at the line, that's where their corners are. They don't trust their safeties. They shouldn't.
[00:50:26] And the general thought is that one of these two units is going to win and the defensive line isn't winning.
[00:50:34] But they're holding their own, they're keeping that even. And the secondary is just letting go of the rope.
[00:50:42] So I can't really, I can't really give a great answer on that right now until I get the all 22 and I see what they're actually trying to do.
[00:50:52] But I can tell you this, whatever they were trying to do didn't go well on the back end. I don't think I need to tell you that. I think we all know that having watched it.
[00:51:00] I think you start against the Vikings D by having Mike Evans back from Duck Star Niners. Yeah, it would. It would certainly help. It would absolutely, certainly help.
[00:51:10] But then you, then you have to start weighing some stuff. Is this a game of such magnitude that you throw caution to the wind?
[00:51:18] Because the risk of bringing Evans back at any point between now and the playoffs. Not that I'm saying that he should sit out until the playoffs. But just the risk of that is the sooner you bring him back, I would venture to say the higher the risk is of re aggravating this to a point of no return.
[00:51:34] Again, as a renowned medical doctor, that would be my guess that we are dealing with a tendonitis and that if that thing flares up again, he might stay on the shelf.
[00:51:49] So what is your level of pain tolerance? Not just physically with Evans, but in terms of risking not having him for games that really mean something. Is having the one seat on the line that important? Because it's still week 11.
[00:52:05] Like you can get it back.
[00:52:07] Not fun to not be in control as we can all attest to just in our day to day lives. But you can get it back.
[00:52:14] So I don't know, I don't know where the chart crosses and that the risk is worth the reward. I don't know.
[00:52:26] But I'll tell you this.
[00:52:27] Mike Evans on the field ups this offense and what they did today does not disqualify them.
[00:52:37] It does enough to at least qualify them to the possibility of beating this Vikings defense because I, I fold me a culpa.
[00:52:45] And we're sitting, we're sitting upstairs, got the kids running around being.
[00:52:50] I have on the, the Vikings packers game for about the first quarter or so before, you know, we got to get down to brass tacks. I was at a birthday party this morning, four year old birthday party. Such an incredible exotic life I live and.
[00:53:03] But I have the game on and I'm watching it and my wife asks like, okay, what's the lowdown on this? As to pander. And my thought was, okay, Vikings defense kind of lay it out. They're blitzing 75% of the time. No one's ever done it 50% of the time. They're doing some insane stuff. Brian Flores has, you know, has entered his villain arc. He's, he's angry at everyone and everything. He's suing the NFL currently.
[00:53:29] Like he's out for blood. Like this is some cool bat that's happening right now and he's the villain. I love it. Can't get enough of it. It's a great storyline. I don't think it's being harped on enough. This guy is just going all in. He's got, he's gone full Rambo, 10 out of 10, no notes.
[00:53:48] And their defense is sick.
[00:53:51] It's disgustingly sick. It is not particularly talented, at least in the conventional sense. And my thought is, and I've been thinking about it, I haven't really been breaking it down.
[00:54:02] So give me some, some leniency here because I'm going to need it in about 10 seconds.
[00:54:08] My thought going into the game against the packers was that the packers were particularly well suited to destroy the Minnesota defense. Because with Minnesota, my thought was, well, kind of like with Seattle last year, if you just stand in there and deliver deep shots down the field, you can get them.
[00:54:30] And that's what we saw with the Rams last year against Seattle. Stafford just stood in there. They could barely run the ball, but man, Stafford just took hit after hit right to the solar plexus and delivered 40 yard daggers on dagger concepts down the field. And it broke, broke it up. And that's effectively what Seattle and even more so, at least conceptually in my mind, Minnesota was doing, which is if you can get it over the top of us, you got all day, but we don't think that you can get get it there. And I'm looking at Green Bay's offense over these last couple weeks and they can't run the ball. They just functionally cannot run the ball.
[00:55:10] Of course that would bear out. Why can't they run the ball? Because their offensive line's no good and their running backs suck. Well, both of those things are kind of important when you're trying to pass protect. But my thought was that they're basically turn their offense and I called this in the shows these week, like this, the bomb from NFL Blitz. Just start running. One of you take a post, one of you do a skinny post and one of you do a nine route and Jordan love just Toyota thons that thing as far as he can. And my thought was that actually stood a real shot if he could just stand in there and take the shots.
[00:55:40] That didn't pan out, at least in the portion of the game I watched. And I only imagine it got worse from there seeing the final score.
[00:55:47] So I don't know what the hell works against it. I'll tell you this though. Brock Purdy has had some real Kyle Shanahan and Brock purdy and this 49ers team have had some real issues with the who's coming, who's going defenses, some real issues. And I don't think that fundamentally Kyle Shanahan is going to change his ethos on these things, which is the answer is always in the play. Yeah, but can you get to the answer fast enough?
[00:56:11] That means you have to find the answer. This is an escape room. And the timer's on two seconds.
[00:56:16] Not sure you're going to get the Clues there, Bubs. Maybe you should have some other answers immediately there. Maybe you should take some safe routes and a wrinkle here, there. Now, today you saw a couple of those with obviously the McCaffrey, Texas route. One of them was improvised. The other one was very clearly a choice route. Texas, whatever the hell you want to call it, usually turns into an angle route. And those were immediate answers to blitzes.
[00:56:44] Okay, Minnesota knows that. They're going to cover that. What's your second? What's your third? Because you might have to get to your third or your fourth in terms of answers on the play, and that might not be very deep down the field.
[00:56:57] It may or may not. I don't know. This is going to be the biggest schematic test they've perhaps ever faced.
[00:57:05] It's one thing when you're facing Kansas City and they're like, we're bumping you, do something about it. That's not a schematic issue. That's a personnel issue. Schematically, this defense is built to kill in the same way that the Mike McDonald defenses are built to kill, except just ratcheted all the way up. Which does mean, as we've seen, the Niners beat Seattle's defense a couple times now.
[00:57:28] It does mean that you can do it.
[00:57:32] But I'm going to spend all week trying to figure out just a couple of things that they can do. And then, guess what?
[00:57:38] The game starts and it's about to go in every which direction, and you better have a much, many more options than anything I could come up with. Having Evans there is going to be huge if he's there.
[00:57:49] You're at an inherent disadvantage not being able to just blindly throw a ball towards number five.
[00:57:55] That might be your only offensive play, as evidenced in the game that we saw against Seattle earlier this year, where it's like, hey, we can't move the ball. We can't worth a damn blindly throw it to 5. They want a game. There's a Mike Evans drive. You can all mentally go back to it.
[00:58:10] I'm not. I'm not sure what it is against Minnesota. I'm extremely excited to find out. Extremely excited. Not, not terribly excited to rewatch the defense of the Niners on this game. We'll do it. That is our duty here. But very excited to get into the Minnesota film because this has been something that I think is defining of the 2026 NFL season. The Minnesota defense, amongst many other things, including Brock purdy and the 49ers offense.
[00:58:36] So this is a true. You know, I think Nate Tyson on 301 calls them like boss or hoss battles. Like, this is. This is it.
[00:58:44] If you're into the. If you're into the heavy stuff, if you're into the esoteric in the NFL, this is.
[00:58:52] This is everything you could ever want more.
[00:58:55] I'd venture to say, though, going into this, I feel like the defense has an advantage because I've seen the defense have the advantage against Brock Purdy in situations like this before.
[00:59:05] Fascinated to find out how it goes. But yeah, having Mike Evans, kind of a big deal. Having Mike Evans is kind of a big deal. Joshua Cantrell, just a macro playoff view. The Niners, who you were playing in for the first or second seed because of the south and East. Also Seattle not dead yet in the West. No, they are not. No, they are not. These are two huge games and we could be having a very different conversation. As negative as I typically am about the Niners, we could be having a very different conversation post Thanksgiving. And you're going into New York and the house of horrors that is MetLife Stadium on December 6th, and you're not feeling as hot about San Francisco. And again, we're starting here, so imagine how low that could be. These are two.
[00:59:46] They're not must wins. You win one of them, you're feeling very good about your situation. I'm not sure which one you'd prefer, but yeah.
[00:59:55] Yeah. This is again why I had a hard time getting all rose colored glasses with the Niners at the trade deadline. This was an op. That was their opportunity to create a little bit more separation. That was their opportunity to create more insulation for themselves and more separation from the package.
[01:00:12] And I don't see much separation right now. I really don't. And we're going to find out how much they have or don't have these next two weeks because it could be very well on, could be very well. It could also be totally off. And they're just coasting on through. We're going to find out. But that's why it's fun. That's why we play the games.
[01:00:31] CG Snipe. Colby's.
[01:00:34] Colby's base is slash. Seems bad. That's my guess. Please correct me if I'm wrong. His hips are not where they belong. Never have been, never will be. Which makes him a horrible and pass pro. He's off balance, sending the sport. Keep it up. Thank you, CG Snipe. And also, that is the best Cyclones helmet they've ever worn, only closely rivaled by the early 2000s actual cyclone bird helmet, which I was kind of a fan of, but not into the sort of like, you know, faux retro. I state one your Iowa State. Get weird with it. Be quirky. Also, while we're at it, Miami, bring back the actual hurricane logo. Just a thought. So, yeah, this is the we.
[01:01:19] Jake and I watched Connor Colby, and Jake and I agree on a lot of things. It's probably why the show started in the first place. I know that people do prefer conflict. That is why we bring Larry on once a week to talk to me.
[01:01:29] Larry and I have the utmost respect for each other. We very rarely see the game the same way. He's gotten his licks in, I get mine in. And we've been right and wrong about many things. Regardless. Jake and I usually see things the same way.
[01:01:42] Not all things, but in the case of Connor Colby, we both were emphatic in our dislike of his tape at Iowa. And for me, Jake really approaches it on a more holistic level. He's actually taking. I'm sorry, he's taking it. He's taking it as the tape is right. He's not taking in sort of the larger picture with stuff. And this is not a knock on him at all. This is just how we approach things. I've been in the college football space for a long time. I have a lot of people in college football. I would like to think that I understand a lot of the ethos and or ethi and a lot of the people that make up the programs and what they teach and how they teach it and what they're all about. And I take those things into account then trying to understand as well what's happening at the NFL level and if those two things mesh.
[01:02:33] So my concern with Conor Colby when I watched the film was that he was a dancing bear and that he was just ballerina everywhere. And when it hit, it looks spectacular because it's crazy athletic. And yeah, I mean, you see when Trent Williams blows a dude up, it is.
[01:02:52] Stop the presses. This is the coolest thing I've ever seen. Well, Trent Williams is doing that from a place of solidity.
[01:02:59] He's not giving up anything to get that crazy athletic explosion where he's again committing war crimes, as he did several times today.
[01:03:07] Connor Colby is completely selling out to do it. He is the equivalent of a Chris Davis home run hitter as opposed to a prime Mike Trout home run hitter.
[01:03:17] You know, Trent Williams might as well be Ted Williams at this point because he can give you 40 home runs a year and he's also going to hit close to.400, right? Like, that's, that's. That the swing is perfect, the base, the fundamentals are perfect. And sometimes the ball hits the bat just right that it goes on forever. Or you can be Chris Davis or any of my Chicago White Sox, where it's like, if I just swing really, really hard at this and just uppercut the bejesus out of it, that ball is going to go a super long way. Yeah, but what about all the times you don't?
[01:03:50] And that's Connor Colby, and this is something that happened last year when he got thrown into the lion's den against the Saints. He comes in maybe a bit more reserved, right? It would be great. He's not a.
[01:04:05] A very open talker. I would love to have had a. Relate or have a relationship with Connor Colby that has not made itself availed to me, and I don't think it will. And I've talked to a lot of people about him. That's never a great sign when I have to talk to other people about him instead of just talking to him. Whereas, you know, the other Niners offensive linemen are all very forthright. And I'm not trying to be, you know, explain yourself to me. I'm just trying to better understand it, because heaven knows, even If I know 1% of offensive line play, and maybe I know more about offensive line play than the average person, I don't know squat compared to anyone who's at the NFL level.
[01:04:47] Right.
[01:04:48] There's a reason somebody who is.
[01:04:51] I've been dropping the pounds, but, like, there's a reason that somebody who naturally carries 6 foot 9, 350 pounds, is only sniffing an NFL locker room because he's a member of the media. Because I suck at it overtly. Like, painfully, like, annoyingly suck at it because there's only so many people my size on this planet and. And what a waste of talent. I didn't have the talent to begin with. Can't waste what you don't have.
[01:05:15] So I do try to, you know, I'll always maybe give a little bit more deference to offensive linemen. I'll always be more curious about offensive linemen. I do not ascribe to the mushroom theory of put them in a closet, feed them shit, and then hope that they grow. I want to better understand this, and they are relative to me, geniuses in this front. I don't have a relationship with Connor Colby that way. Every conversation I've had with him has been very short.
[01:05:43] It's not a Personal thing. I, I don't think, even if it is fair play to him, he just, he's not a talker. Fair enough.
[01:05:52] I can't quite put my finger on why it was. Why it is that he starts the season playing well, though this year. There's an argument that he didn't, but why the play just deteriorates over the weeks, why it keeps getting worse. One aspect of this is certainly tape.
[01:06:14] Other teams get the tape and they go, oh, that guy, let's go at him.
[01:06:19] I would do that, too.
[01:06:21] But then there's the whole counter Colby of it all.
[01:06:24] What are you doing to counter any of this? And there's no evidence he's doing any of it. There's no evidence to it. He could be the most hard working, earnest, smartest, whatever. It's not evident. We're not seeing it. And so I just don't know how long this can go on for. I mean, last year they, they pulled his ass.
[01:06:45] That game was so bad that it's worthy of a benching. They don't have the insulation there. They weren't going to get it a trade deadline. For whatever it's worth.
[01:06:53] That is one thing that I don't hold against the Niners at the trade deadline, because they should have gone and gotten a third tight end. They should have gone and gotten somebody in the secondary. If not two people in the secondary, elite pass rusher, don't think they're available. But hey, I'm open minded to it. But in the concept of, oh, you go get, you know, insulation on the offensive line from whom, who's giving up any competition? The level of offensive line play in this league is as bad as it's ever been.
[01:07:22] People are trading for bad offensive linemen, much less ones that can help you. So you could have gotten a draft pick for Connor Colby if you put him on the market. So I don't. I just, I do not know. But it is the same stuff that we were seeing at Iowa and going back to that sort of initial premise, you know, Jake hated the tape. I hated the tape. And the fact that he was at Iowa and doing that, because that's the opposite of Iowa football.
[01:07:51] And so there is some level of, well, you know, they put up with it. Maybe there's something there. At the same time, if Iowa is not coaching it out of him, Chris first sure as hell ain't like Iowa's entire thing is we find these guys, we plump them up and then we develop them from basically scratch.
[01:08:10] They couldn't get this guy he played a lot of football. They couldn't get this guy to get any better at Iowa. They couldn't get this guy to be the toughest nails in your face. Tristan Worf, Nick. Name all the great Iowa players. There's a lot of them. There's such a high floor for an Iowa offensive lineman in the NFL if they have even the requisite physical traits. Connor Colby has all the requisite physical traits.
[01:08:34] This is another example of firster getting a little high on his own supply. Again, not the best choice of wording. But alas, here we are. Blame my subconscious.
[01:08:47] Enrique Cruz, Connor Colby, a lot of guys he has looked at high ceiling, low floor and said, I can get them there.
[01:08:59] The problem is it's not incremental.
[01:09:03] The problem is if you have this really high ceiling and this really low floor, it doesn't just slowly ratchet up.
[01:09:10] Progress isn't linear progress and it's usually just 0 to 100. You either got it or you don't. And to this point, there's no evidence that Connor Colby has it. There's no evidence that he'll ever find has not gotten better. He consistently plays worse. They're consistently targeting him more on other opposing defenses, game plans and the fact that they don't have insulation there is a sin of the off season and injuries and bad luck and all these things. But like, it's a real issue. If the secondary wasn't again Mao's china right now with all the red flags, we'd be only talking about Conor Colby right now because that's the way I roll. We talk about the bad shit all the time. But because the secondary is so bad, the Connor Colby thing probably gets brushed under the rug.
[01:09:58] But I'm willing to bet we're talking about it late Sunday night.
[01:10:02] That's my bet.
[01:10:03] Thank you for the super chat. Might join late, but no one answered my question. We got guys on the dm, we got Bosa osa, this is Reuben by the way, Buckner, Michael White, etc, Height and Valdez. Why are we buns? Pertaining sacks, like who's the overrated pass rusher? Who's the overrated pass rusher, do you think?
[01:10:27] I think they've just played some quarterbacks that are very good at avoiding sacks recently.
[01:10:31] And I think that it's really hard to get sacks when your secondary is just leaving dudes wide open.
[01:10:37] Again, worry about the pressure and I see them getting pressure, I see them forcing off balance throws, I see them making quarterback second guess. I saw, you know, the two weeks prior to this quarterbacks being so afraid of them that they were just getting rid of the ball before they could even run a real play.
[01:10:53] This week it was, we're getting in your face.
[01:10:57] We're doing average to above average pass rush.
[01:11:02] But our secondary is so bad that it just doesn't matter. I mean just, just go back. I, I tweeted this out at the end of the game. There's a guy who does like pretty immediate cut ups on Twitter of highlights of both college and NFL and until he gets taken down, you should follow him. You can go on on my Twitter. It's like the first thing I did and it was like a George Pickens highlight tape.
[01:11:26] These aren't contested catches.
[01:11:28] Like he's nowhere. Lenore is nowhere near him most of the game.
[01:11:33] So it doesn't really matter if you have pressure in the a gap across the, you know, coming out from the outside. If you got guys coming at the ball. If Dak Prescott standing there and he's like, well, if I only need three, you know, two and a half, three seconds and Pickens is going to be wide open, I can just lock in on him.
[01:11:50] The way you get sacks is really, and we saw this I think twice today, certainly once with Purdy is coverage sacks. Nobody's open.
[01:11:59] Nobody's open. So now we're two, three seconds into this play. Nobody's open. I can't deliver the ball. I gotta make something happen. Oh, guess what? There's a guy in my lap.
[01:12:07] I would venture to say that time to pressure for the 49ers is fine. Time to sack is clearly nil.
[01:12:13] Because you don't need any time, you don't get any time to sack. When your time to pressure isn't exceptional because your secondary is ensuring that whatever the quarterback sees he can take.
[01:12:29] So that that's the ball game right now. If you improve the secondary, the sack numbers are going to go up. So long as the defensive line continues to play at this level, if the secondary is going to continue to be this bad, you're not going to get sacks.
[01:12:42] And again we, Penix and Cousins were out there playing hot potato. Dak Prescott stood in there and delivered. He can move around a little bit, mostly to the right. They took that away today. I would argue Cousins again you're going to get next week. No idea who your quarterback is for the Seattle, but I'm not, I'm just not as concerned about this. And I think that it is, I think it's kind of rudimentary football understanding from the folks that Are really pushing this narrative right now because it takes two to tango.
[01:13:15] If your secondary isn't guarding anybody, you would need basically to win at off the line of scrimmage every single play. In order to actually bring down a quarterback, you would have to have like Jadevion Clowney. What was a Gator bowl level defensive end play?
[01:13:36] Like, oh, they just didn't touch him and he's directly in the lap and the play immediately devolved.
[01:13:41] Like when people use the term game wrecker, very rarely are plays actually wrecked. There are confluence of many things. You're going to need some coverage on the back end.
[01:13:51] Otherwise what's the quarterback afraid of?
[01:13:54] He's going to be able to get the ball out before these guys get to him. And it's not because the guys are getting to him slower than other teams.
[01:14:01] It's because there's nothing that he's looking at that's deterring him from pulling the trigger on pretty much his first option.
[01:14:09] That's where I stand on it now. And when I watch the tape I might have a different opinion on it. But watching the game and only seeing the defensive line play and not really getting to see the full back end but certainly seeing the wide open receptions, my guess is it's a secondary issue and not a defensive line issue because I did see a lot of pressure today and I did see Dak Prescott making off balance throws and I did see him make him bad throws in this game.
[01:14:33] But he was always making the throws. You know why? Because he wasn't having to double clutch once, not a once.
[01:14:41] He could see it and he could deliver it. Not always perfectly, but he could as my helmet play. Oh yeah. Shout out cg.
[01:14:51] That's before my time to be fair. But that is a sweet helmet and they should bring it back. That's my official stance. We're going to get Brock on it. He has some sway in the organization. Ruben again, almost everything streamer is blaming the D line. It's a secondary. Who can we bring in? Are we?
[01:15:06] You're not but you might be.
[01:15:10] The.
[01:15:12] The secondary.
[01:15:14] Secondary is kind of a black box for me. Obviously at my shape didn't spend a lot of time learning about the secondary so everything I'm doing is pretty new. Jake probably has a better read on this than me and he'll definitely lay it on you tomor. But yeah, they're gonna. They're gonna have to. They're gonna have to at least just pick a route again, pardon the pun and go with it at safety. I think that's a place to start. Pick two safeties. Pick them. I don't have to like it. I probably won't like it. Just pick two and go with it and figure out a role for the third one.
[01:15:49] I would actually say that, you know, maybe I would prefer to see, you know, Jair sort of a Sam backer and sort of a quasi dime nickel situation. Okay, that's my preference. Whatever.
[01:16:01] Do Mustafa there.
[01:16:03] Put Siegel in the slot. Like do something.
[01:16:06] You got to do something. Because this rotation I don't think helps communication at all. And communication isn't the entirety of their issues, but it's certainly an issue as evidenced with the Raider game, and I'm certain it's going to show up in this game as well.
[01:16:19] Lenore and Green being injured is not ideal.
[01:16:23] I don't think they're going to get any less injured, but. And I don't think they're going to be practicing very much down the stretch, which also does not help.
[01:16:32] I might be fucked. But again, you have to feel better about it for the from the 49ers perspective that Raheem Morris is the guy back there who's got to figure it out. Not sure he will, but I feel a lot better about Raheem Morris figuring out a secondary than I have about any other 49ers defensive coordinator under Kyle Shanahan.
[01:16:54] Maybe. Maybe he's just riding on a reputation that's no longer deserved. We're about to find out.
[01:16:58] We're about to find out. And I will be spending some time tomorrow to be sure, scouring to see cornerbacks that are worthy of practice squad pickups because they need some bodies there. And again, they really needed to do this with.
[01:17:16] They really needed to do this at the trade deadline and just getting in another body, somebody who's serviceable and maybe Nate Hobbs changes things for them there. But I don't think Ephesians pry sock like covered himself in glory today. You still have Jack Jones as a depth corner. I'm not feeling great about any of it, but you roll with what you got and it would probably help to just pick a lane, pick a lane.
[01:17:43] And for everybody blaming the D line. Yeah, I bet they are.
[01:17:47] I bet they are because I don't think they could explain. I mean, I have a hard enough time explaining the differences in the higher numbered coverages as is. I don't think they could even recognize it if they saw it. It's not a personal thing. I don't, you know, I don't think that their audience cares about that kind of stuff I think our audience does. And we try to constantly educate ourselves and talk to people who are much, much smarter than us about this. Certainly offline so as to not embarrass ourselves.
[01:18:13] But, like, that's not their lane and they're watching the game on TV like everybody else and going, why no sack?
[01:18:21] Again, I'm not saying the defensive line played well. I'm just saying I don't think that they looked out of place. I don't think that they looked stonewalled in this game. And we'll talk about it tomorrow. We'll have a much better feel on one way or another tomorrow.
[01:18:37] Yeah, the Jewels are back. Hooray for the Jewels. I think it helps with.
[01:18:46] I think it helps with the. The algo Colby is the deeter of Daniel Brunskill.
[01:18:52] We're going to end with that because I still have no idea what that means, but I'm gonna be thinking about it for a long time. Thank you to everyone who, who joined in tonight. Jake and I will be back tomorrow, presumably almost certainly to. To break this film down.
[01:19:08] That's probably not going to be a very cheery episode. We will do our best to highlight some of the really cool offensive stuff they did in this game.
[01:19:16] Frankly, it was so overt. I think you saw it. You don't need the breakdown. But we'll do our best to. To balance it out.
[01:19:23] We will have a better feel on what happened with this secondary once this all 22 tape hits. We'll have a better feel on if the. The defensive line is in fact to blame.
[01:19:32] But we're going. I'm going in, I'm going in with. With an open mind to any direction as to what's going right, what's going wrong and who's to blame and who's not to blame. Whatever.
[01:19:46] I'm, I'm very open minded. This is going to be an extremely interesting week. I mean, Jake and I off camera were talking where we were like, man, I don't. I'm not feeling a lot of juice right now. And we were so excited about, you know, this year in the show and it's been incredible to see the, the support and the feedback and all that stuff, and we loved it. And then, you know, the bye week hits and coming off a loss, not that again. We care who wins and loses, but coming off a loss, it takes a lot of wind out of the sails, right? And you get the buy. You get a little off, and then you're like, oh, boy, I get to watch A Raiders film. Hooray.
[01:20:23] And then this week with the Cowboys, you're like, oh, defense, bad offense. Okay, so this is the first week where in a while where we're getting something that is pretty overtly awesome.
[01:20:38] Pretty overtly awesome in the Vikings defense and in theory also, you know, and I think this will bear out when we we go through the tape tomorrow. The 49ers offense.
[01:20:49] This might be the first time we've seen something truly awesome against the 49ers since week five, week four when we saw the Denver and Seattle defenses back to back.
[01:21:02] I will note that we haven't seen an elite quarterback go up against the 49ers this season.
[01:21:10] And yeah, I include the NFL's reigning MVP in that conversation.
[01:21:15] Dak Prescott might actually be the closest thing we've seen that should be noted.
[01:21:20] I don't think that that is actually going to be the case. Well, down the stretch we already laid off everything because you do get Patrick Mahomes in theory on December 27. But they might go a long time without having faced a quarterback at the top of his game and at the top of the league.
[01:21:37] That's something to note moving forward.
[01:21:40] So I would just keep that in the back of your head. Excited to talk to you guys all tomorrow. Thank you so much for joining us tonight.
[01:21:48] Hit us up in the comments. I think that this might be a good week to to do. We always try to take questions and stuff but for some of the members hit us up and we'll try to do more questions that are maybe overarching for this week as well. It might just be me, might just be Jake answering them. But if you want to get in some maybe bigger picture questions and obviously some stuff that pertains to this week might be a good week for a mailbag of sorts. So hit, hit us up in the comments on that and we'll get to all the members comments or we'll try to. We try to do it every episode. Obviously today was crazy in the live chat. I'm riding solo so appreciate all the super chats. Makes it a lot easier for me to sort it out. Oh, you gave me money. Yeah, we'll we'll read those but sorry to anybody I didn't get to on that front. And yeah, hit us up in the comment section of this video and we will try to get to some of these bigger picture questions because listen, we're trying to think about all this stuff all the time. A lot of times you guys have much better ideas than we do and we're very fortunate to have those ideas being brought to the forefront, getting us thinking about it, and we'll see where we all end up together again. Excited to talk to you guys tomorrow. I've only said that about seven times now. I'm legitimately excited to talk to you guys tomorrow. And we'll talk to you guys tomorrow. And we're excited about it. Bye.